So much average

Simply A Masterpiece

Good concept, poorly executed.

As Good As It Gets

Previous comments praise the producer for accurate realism but within seconds of turning this film on I spotted that the one of the 'jeeps' was a post war British Landrover. The US commandos were armed with Garrands and Thompsons but also with a British Bren gun not the BAR you'd expect. The German Aircrew were flying a Canadian Post war DH Chipmunk unarmed trainer and the flying suits were decidedly not tropical issue. Many other films have portrayed the battle between the men, the enemy and the desert much better. 'Ice cold in Alex' being the benchmark and 'Sea of sand' aka 'desert patrol' being a superior example.

An Italian WW2 flick that turns out to be decent rather than the usual decidedly average level for this sub-genre. The worst thing about BATTLE OF THE DAMNED is the storyline, which is full of the stock clichés, stock characters, and stock situations from a dozen other similar genre entries. Hell, even the plot is almost exactly the same as others I've seen.The storyline sees a crack squad of American soldiers who are tasked with blowing up a German fuel depot deep in the desert. What transpires is a desert-set story of survival and death, with the usual incidents we see in these movies: the jeep breaks down, the survivors go on foot, have to deal with in-fighting and the wounded, before things pick up for a rousing, action-packed climax.Director Roberto Montero has established a decent genre cast for his film, including recognisable faces like that of Giacomo Rossi-Stuart, Fabio Testi, and Luciano Catenacci; such actors can be relied upon to give tough, realistic performances and they don't disappoint with their roles here. Montero, who spent his career churning out war flicks, spaghetti westerns, gialli, and erotic movies, shoots his film ably and the action, when it hits, is well staged, particularly that climax. Despite the familiarity of the storyline and action there's little to dislike about this dependable Italian B-flick.

Director Robert Bianchi Montero's first step into the war genre turns out to be something of a scared step – he has a good story to tell, but whenever he can take it in a new and unique direction, everything stalls and falls back on established, guaranteed clichés. That said, this is a pretty average desert-war flick.The plot is a simple combination of two decent American war films, namely "Play Dirty", and also "Tobruk". A small band of misfit American commandos are assigned to head across the North African desert to blow up a huge German fuel depot. Why this fuel depot is important is explained in an overly long introduction, comprised of narrated black and white stock footage. That introduction is just a time-killer, but once it's out of the way, the fun begins.Montero relies on his cast of young Italian actors to give the film its energy, and they pull it off masterfully. The only American in the batch is Dale Cummings, whose only other notable credit is in a later Bianchi war film, "The Rangers". Cummings plays Captain Clay, whose reputation as a dangerous commander precedes him. Marwell (Maurice Poli, "The Longest Day") tries to warn the others in the unit that Clay will get them all killed. Unfortunately, Montero fails to take this conflict anywhere substantial – he confines this conflict to some occasional verbal sparring between Marwell and Clay, and seems to disregard it altogether as the film progresses.The supporting characters add some much-needed juice to supplement the leads. Sgt. Dean (Luciano Catenacci, "Hell in Normandy") tries to keep the dissension among the men at a minimum. Maurizio Tocchi and Fabio Testi (both co-starred in "A Place in Hell") provide good support, as well. As they trek across the desert, complication after complication threatens the success of the mission: a German plane strafes their jeeps, damaging one and wounding a man. Then there's a lack of water and inability to get in touch with the rear.Montero pays close attention to getting the details of the time period and setting correct, and this adds a great deal to the realistic feel and tone of the film. The Germans are properly armed and wear the right kind of uniforms, as do the American commandos. The exteriors, shot in Egypt, make the vast Sahara desert look appropriately bleak.Bianchi keeps the action to a minimum, focusing on the conflicts within the group and saving the German threat for the final act. This final act is a truly rousing and suspenseful finale, as members of the unit penetrate the colossal underground fuel dump and then must fight their way out before the explosive charges detonate. This finale is filled with nail-biting scenes and surprises, including the appearance of a key German character from earlier in the film. Only some of the good guys survive, and those who die go down like heroes.What's unfortunate is that Montero doesn't do anything new and unusual with his film. Every line of dialog sounds very familiar to war film buffs and the action scenes have a very typical look and feel to them. It's too bad, because the cast was capable of handling much more sophisticated material – most of the main cast has proved this in their own right in other films.When compared to other films, "Battle of the Damned" really has nothing new to offer. It's simply a good time-filler, with some fair action scenes and performances thrown in place it a notch above many other movies of the same time period. Montero would do somewhat better later on in "Thirty-Six Hours of Hell", a similarly-themed movie set in the Pacific with more substance.6/10