An examination of the creation of the state of Israel in 1948 through to the present day. A semi-biographic film, in four chapters, about a family spanning from 1948 until recent times. Combined with intimate memories of each member, the film attempts to portray the daily life of those Palestinians who remained in their land and were labelled "Israeli-Arabs," living as a minority in their own homeland.
Similar titles
You May Also Like
Reviews
Simply A Masterpiece
Awesome Movie
One of the worst ways to make a cult movie is to set out to make a cult movie.
The film never slows down or bores, plunging from one harrowing sequence to the next.
This film has a very distinguished style and sense of humor for such a dark topic on the conflict of Israel and Palestine. It reflects three generations of the conflict through the perspective of Es (the protagonist) who plays a child, a teenager and an elder man. He never speaks perhaps as a metaphor representing the voiceless. One thing I was also able to appreciate as an Egyptian audience, the Egyptian songs by Laila Mourad and Mohamed Abdel Wahab, as well as some Egyptian news references, like on the death of Egypt's President Gamal Abdel Nasser in 1970. Something that a Western audience may not at all experience in the same way a Middle Eastern or Arabic Audience would, is almost like a cheery on the icing for people of that culture, a little gift made exclusively for us, that only we can feel nostalgic about and understand the reference to that culture and era. This film portrays the issue as a gray issue and does no only show the oppressive and inhuman acts of the Israeli Militants, like when they throw Es' father off a cliff. A few scenes show a very human side to them as well, like in the scene when they call out to stop a dance party because of curfew, the first idea that came to mind was the cultural deprivation, but when the military figures start dancing to the music track, it highlights that both sides unite by liking the same music. In another scene, when Israeli military move furniture items onto a truck, the listen to music and smoke cigarettes, somehow very subtly reveals them as ordinary military base figures on duty, it does not look so different from Egyptian bases. He also does not glorify all Palestinians as victims. We get to see a Palestinian who joins the Israeli military and is perceived as a traitor, and called out on it, but he explains later how he needs the work to feed his family. Another very interesting portrayal of how a land under an occupation becomes so natural and part of the backdrop and landscape of the environment, like in the scene when a guy on the cell phone who walks back and forth is pointed at with a tank tracking his every move. The guy does not react at all. This film had a very promising subtle message that the issue is gray and complicated and it seems to be a wish to focus on the good sides in both sides and bringing people together.
A post-horrific movie. A half century plus of Israeli-Arab life as lived mainly in Nazareth. As depicted, the gradual erosion of Arab social life move the characters from inchoate normalcy to Beckettian realism. But since violence is muted virtually throughout the five to six decades shown, this viewer was left with a strange flatness of effect since Langdon and Tati-like staging dehumanized much of what I saw because of how the director composed the shots and how he directed the actors. Perhaps he was emotionally stunted by living through some of the history shown but his reaction.....his movie.....repelled me by his tiresome, repetitive remove from it all; he never showed the day-to-day-to-year-to-year horror of it all that made the absurdity understandable. There was no "middle" to the movie.
This film, like most Elia Suleiman films, uses real time, absurdity, symbolism and scenes from Suleiman's life, at the same time portraying history and current events. As typical of Suleiman it is also a very personal film, the most personal of the ones I've seen (Divine Intervention, Chronicle of a Disappearance). It is a reminiscence of his family from the time of 1948, when the state of Israel was created on the land called Palestine, to the present day.The film covers events including the war of 1948, the death of Nasser, the resistance against Israeli occupation, and the deterioration of Palestinian society in recent times. It is filled with Suleiman's typical tragicomic scenes of interaction between Israelis and Palestinians. It is a very sad film, however, the humor that runs through the film, and the suspense that is created by filming in real time, keep the film engaging even though like Suleiman's other films the pace is somewhat slow.
As was the case for 'Divine Intervention', Elia Suleiman's former masterpiece, the viewer can't help but admire the originality of its style. What a wonderful thing that a Palestinian should be able to evoke the situation prevailing in his motherland and the Israeli-Palestinian conflict not in a full-frontal, simplistic, dogmatic way (which would be forgivable given the circumstances) but in an unexpected, humorous, quirky, poetic fashion, a little as if Harry Langdon, Buster Keaton and Jacques Tati had decided to tackle geopolitics for once. Suleiman's talent is really offbeat : contemplation in preference to action (the narrator played by Suleiman himself observes more than he acts); silence rather than significant dialog (the main protagonists hardly ever speak and those who express themselves the most are secondary characters saying only superficial things); symbolism before realism (the Israeli taxi driver lost in the turmoil of a summer storm, not knowing where he is going, not recognizing his country anymore).Occasionally very funny (the Iraqi soldier who can't find the battlefield; the gun of a tank following the coming and going of a young Palestinian in the process of taking out his trash bag and talking on his mobile phone without caring the least bit about the threat), 'The Time That remains' contains crazy gags which are a relevant reflection of the absurd atmosphere reigning in Palestine. But most of the time, the film consists in the poetic account of the odd life Palestinians are forced to live, concentrating mainly on the director's parents,a shy but loving mother and a fearless rebellious father, to whom the director pays homage. Not the type to wear his heart on his sleeve, Suleiman expresses his filial love with discretion and restraint. The scenes with his mother aged eighty and with his father dying in the car are particularly moving.'The Time That Remains' looks like no other film of any sort. Go and see it.