Sadly Over-hyped

Don't listen to the negative reviews

Although it has its amusing moments, in eneral the plot does not convince.

It is neither dumb nor smart enough to be fun, and spends way too much time with its boring human characters.

We often see on internet news websites little bits and snips of "weird news", things that seem too bizarre, too inexplicable to be real. The story of John Wood and Shannon Whisnant is one of these stories. Through this documentary, we get a rare glimpse into the lives of the people behind the strange and altogether unlikely series of events that brought two very different men from Carolina together in a battle over, of all things, an amputated leg.John Wood lost his leg in a fatal plane crash that saw the father he loved, Tom, die. Already a troubled man, the trauma of the crash sent him over the edge, with drug abuse and alienation from his family causing him to enter into a downward spiral. Eventually, everything he owned ended up in a storage unit. Desperate for something to have to reconcile with the event, he took claim of his own amputated limb, and eventually preserved it through a bit of backwoods mummification. It was among the possessions in the shed that was eventually sold to a wheeling-dealing haggler named Shannon Whisnant. Discovering the foot in an old grill, Shannon claimed ownership of the foot after it was discovered to be a medically amputated limb. John wanted it back. The ensuing media attention to the story would change the lives of both men, though to the public at large, it was just another story of Southern-fried strangeness and backwoods idiocy.Starting with the story of the leg itself, the strange set of circumstances which saw it amputated from its owner and its backwoods method of mummification, the documentary then transitions into the story of the battle over the severed leg, before examining the lives of two men who are, at their core, damaged in more ways than just physical scars and amputated appendages. John, a recovering addict who desperately sought the approval and love of his parents. Shannon, physically abused by his father, like many people in the age of reality television and internet broadcasting desperately seeks fame and recognition.Although it is an easy trap for many to focus solely on the lurid details of the leg and the battle for it that ensued shortly thereafter, the documentary succeeds in telling a story that you aren't likely to see on reality TV or the internet, examining the lives of both men in an ultimately sympathetic way. About the only fault that can be said for the film is that, while the story is interesting, the documentary becomes thoroughly average. Neither terrible nor exemplary, it succeeds at telling its story from a new and refreshing angle, but the tale it tells is simply not one that is overwhelmingly engrossing. It's competent, and it does an excellent job of taking a look at its subjects in a way that no one prior had even bothered to attempt. But there is only so much story you can get out of the struggle over a severed foot. That and perhaps it is a little too lenient in its examination of the exploitation of these two men by a news and entertainment media that was clearly interested only in the bloody details.

Maybe it's because I am in Ohio, and this took place in North Carolina, but I don't recall hearing anything about this public feud over a leg found in a smoker that was sold off in a storage unit auction. There are many different types of documentaries -- historical, biographical, ones that take on social, environmental or political issues, but soon into this film, I ascertained it to be I guess a comedic doc-?? Well, a bit farther into it, I realized there is more to this than I thought. In fact, I would call this a documentary about healing, recovering from addiction, and making amends. Definitely worth checking out sometime...

I can't fault this really stunning documentary.When the director stumbled across the numerous eccentric characters who made up this film, I'm sure he couldn't have believed his luck. However instead of ridiculing the characters, he sensitively lets them tell their own stories in their own way. Make no mistake - the end result will make you laugh out loud, which is why you should watch it in a crowd. However much of the humour comes from the editing rather than cheap shots at the characters' expense, and you will find yourself respecting both them and the director.You'll also spend much of the movie thinking you are watching a mockumentary, since most of the stars are outstandingly telegenic, and the story - well it's too bizarre to be fiction.The soundtrack is superb, as are the editing, the direction, the way the clips are woven into a story with a history and an ending, the attention to detail, and even the camera work.Happy to give up a couple of hours of my time to this movie, and anything else by the same director.

This is documentary filmmaking at its best, filled with hilarity, surprising twists and turns, eccentric characters, and poignant revelations. The film is brilliantly constructed from bits of news footage, beautifully photographed interviews, and quirky bits of animation that highlight the timeline of events. It's actually one of the best edited films of any kind that I have ever seen. Add to that a quirky soundtrack that's as unique as the real-life characters themselves, plus a story so bizarre it has to be witnessed to be believed — and you've got one absolutely remarkable film. It is best to come to this film without any preconceptions or expectations, so I am not even touching on elements of the story. This movie is a gem.