Crappy film

I like movies that are aware of what they are selling... without [any] greater aspirations than to make people laugh and that's it.

It's complicated... I really like the directing, acting and writing but, there are issues with the way it's shot that I just can't deny. As much as I love the storytelling and the fantastic performance but, there are also certain scenes that didn't need to exist.

It’s not bad or unwatchable but despite the amplitude of the spectacle, the end result is underwhelming.

The names of Adolphe Menjou and Pola Negri in the cast might lead you to expect the date of this film to be 1923 rather than 1943 (and the two did in fact make a couple of films together that year), but this is actually a relatively late screwball comedy with an on-form once-in-a-lifetime cast (although Denis O'Keefe rather strains credibility as Menjou's son).Billed third, Negri, who was then 46 and hadn't made a film in Hollywood for over ten years (her next and final film was Disney's 'The Moonspinners' twenty years later) actually has a relatively small role as Menjou's wife, but looks great (along with Martha Scott and Billie Burke she sweeps about in a succession of fabulous creations by Adrian) and one gets a rare chance to hear what she actually sounded like. We first meet her singing the Ride of the Valkyries, and Wagner - whose music one character says "had some beautiful moments but some ugly half hours" - is later the victim of a priceless sight gag. The best performance as usual is by Menjou, but right down to the bit players the cast all seem to be enjoying themselves (including veteran composer & musical director Richard Hageman unexpectedly playing the small part of a company director).The same year as he made the all-black musical 'Stormy Weather' the always surprising independent producer-director Andrew L. Stone here shows early evidence of the good naturedness and flair for organising complicated story lines that found full flower in his later thrillers; and this may be his only film to receive an Oscar nomination (for Phil Boutelje's score). Frederick Jackson's screenplay crackles with saucy throwaways and there are some sublime breaches of the fourth wall, including a couple of animated inserts by Friz Freleng.

Andrew Stone produced, directed and wrote the story (which was adapted by Edmund Hartmann and Frederick Jackson) for this wartime screwball comedy featuring an Academy Award nominated Score by Phil Boutelje. Also notable is the appearance of Pola Negri in the cast; this was her first film in years and her last until her final role in The Moon-Spinners (1964). Adolphe Menjou, Martha Scott, Dennis O'Keefe, Billie Burke, Walter Kingsford, and Barton Hepburn play the other significant parts in the movie.The plot is pretty standard stuff for a screwball comedy: it relies on misunderstandings among some wealthy characters - like the always reliable ditz Burke - for its comic payoffs. Menjou plays his typical womanizer, even though he's married to Negri's character, an opera singer he'd charmed six months ago for her money. Paul Porcasi plays her impresario. Menjou's son Sonny (O'Keefe) is a chip off the old block, a sailor in the Navy with a girl in every port until he meets Martha Scott, who's playing a wealthy debutante that's Burke's daughter. O'Keefe's character insists that he's never been in love like this before, a line he uses several times with other women in the film's opening credits, which include cartoon character sequences, as does the film's final scene (of operatic composer Richard Wagner and his family at a picnic!).But as is often the case, Burke's character is really smarter than she looks or acts; she and Hepburn's character have schemed to test O'Keefe's love for her daughter Scott. Burke, a rich widow who socializes with a senator played by Kingsford, pretends to lose all her money to Hepburn, who's ostensibly interested in marrying Scott for himself, in order to see if O'Keefe still wants to marry her. Naturally, their love is stronger than such concerns but, with the prospect of having to support his would-be mother-in-law Burke, O'Keefe engages his "pretending to be wealthy" father Menjou, who's a somewhat impoverished kept man of Negri's, to solve this newly financial problem of his. Menjou's plan involves using a more powerful magnet at the 59 club's (owned by Georges Metaxa's character) crooked roulette table (operated by croupier Eddie Marr) to beat them at their own game. He gets assistance from a longtime associate who's currently the club's singer, June Havoc.There's another scam involving some phony gold mine stock (wasn't there any other type of enterprise that could be used in those days?) which inadvertently fools a real brokerage firm employee (Byron Foulger) and its owner (Richard Hageman). There's also a running joke whereby Lorraine Miller appears in almost every scene (walking her dog on the street, as a hatcheck girl, etc.), noticed by Menjou and eventually labeled a friend of this film's director by Burke. Several requisite false identity gags, who's married to whom etc., also transpire which, when combined with the aforementioned schemes, nearly prevent the newlyweds time from having any alone time. But thanks to the family's maid (Ellen Lowe), O'Keefe and Scott finally get some time to consummate their marriage before he has to ship off again.

This film starts out differently, with an animated sequence before the opening credits. This is the first of several off-beat touches which makes Hi Diddle Diddle an enjoyable film. Pola Negri, former silent star from Valentino's day registers well here as a temperamental opera star. Not only is her voice understandable, but it is downright good here. She is also still quite beautiful in 1943, and it seems a pity that she did not have a bigger career in sound films. The rest of the cast, headed by Adolphe Menjou, Martha Scott, Dennis O'Keefe and Billie Burke are all in top form, and a special mention for a musical sequence featuring June Havoc singing along with herself on a soundie screen. There are some good belly laughs to be had and, all in all, this is a charming piece of forties fluff which will whizz by painlessly enough.

A B film but a very funny comedy starring Martha Scott and Dennis O'Keefe as newlyweds who get caught up in the schemes of daddy (Adolphe Menjou) as he tries to win back mama's (Billie Burke) money at a crooked roulette wheel. Not much on plot but very funny with Menjou's opera singer wife (Pola Negri in her first American film in more than a decade)) singing Wagner at any given moment.The film rushes between standard comedy and weird comments to the camera. There's also a running gag about an actress who is only in the film because she's dating the director. And then there's that animated wallpaper.Co-Stars include June Havoc, who steals the film as a nightclub singer who at one point sings a duet with herself, Walter Kingsford, Bess Flowers, Barton Hepburn, Georges Metaxa, Paul Porcasi, Harry Tyler, Matt McHugh, and Bert Roach. as the flustered cab rider.The real interest here is of course Pola Negri in a talkie ... and she's very funny indeed and looks great.