For all the hype it got I was expecting a lot more!

This is a small, humorous movie in some ways, but it has a huge heart. What a nice experience.

A great movie, one of the best of this year. There was a bit of confusion at one point in the plot, but nothing serious.

The plot isn't so bad, but the pace of storytelling is too slow which makes people bored. Certain moments are so obvious and unnecessary for the main plot. I would've fast-forwarded those moments if it was an online streaming. The ending looks like implying a sequel, not sure if this movie will get one

Barnacle Bill characters are Bimbo (Barnacle Bill), and Betty Boop (the object of Barnacle's affections, voiced by Mae Questel). Director: DAVE FLEISCHER. Animators: Seymour Kneitel, Rudy Zamora. Song, "Barnacle Bill, the Sailor". Producer: Max Fleischer.Copyright 31 August 1930 by Paramount Publix Corp. 1 reel. COMMENT: This first use of the catchy "Barnacle Bill, the Sailor" (with risque lyrics that were cleaned up for the song's subsequent use in a Popeye cartoon), is an inventive offering that presents Bimbo in a more flatteringly aggressive light than usual and allows Fleischer to put his talent for surreal gags to good use (we particularly like the chairs tiptoeing out of Betty's room so that the sofa-which joins in the chorus of the song- can amble in). The final sequence with the lightning is delightfully bizarre, though we wish that Betty could somehow have joined in the climax. Her role here, as in other Bimbos, amounts to just a little more than a guest appearance.

In the first decade or so of sound cartoons, studios tended to make their films with way too much singing and cuteness and way too little humor. So, I do understand the context for "Barnacle Bill"....but I also didn't need to like it, either. The film is sung from start to finish and really lacks humor and entertainment value when seen today. In fact, my score of 3 reflects the film when seen today--perhaps back in 1930 it would have earned a 5 or 6.So is the film worth seeing? Well, it all depends. If you are a huge Betty Boop fan or are a big fan of early animation, it's worth seeing--as it's one of the earliest incarnations of this and the Bimbo character. Now it might be hard to see this as being Betty at first--she has long doggy ears and is animated in a stretched out manner. Bimbo also is VERY different. As far as the story goes, well, there isn't much of one--just lots of singing. The only real plus doesn't surprise me--the background animations were first-rate--which is what you should expect from a Fleischer Brothers cartoon.

Not officially released as a Betty Boop short, but that's Betty and the early Bimbo. Bimbo stayed a canine throughout, while Betty became human. Bimbo comes across as a less than likable sort here, but then neither was Barnacle Bill the sailor (pay attention to the lyrics of the sea chantey). Bimbo was a more or less marginal character, for my tastes, although he was head and shoulders above most of the supporting characters in later years. Koko the Clown was the most effective bit player they used in the Betty Boop series. Bimbo spends most of his time making eyes and sighing at Betty in most of his appearances. The later design on the character was a marked improvement over the original character they show here. This is on the Betty Boop collection that's well worth having. This short is nothing special, but worth a look once.

Betty Boop starts to take more form in this, the second cartoon in which she appeared, although she still has floppy spaniel ears.... yes, Betty was a real dog when she was young!This is one of the animated song cartoons that Fleischer did, and the gags fill out the singing of 'Barnacle Bill'. Not bad.