The thing I enjoyed most about the film is the fact that it doesn't shy away from being a super-sized-cliche;

There's no way I can possibly love it entirely but I just think its ridiculously bad, but enjoyable at the same time.

The acting in this movie is really good.

Each character in this movie — down to the smallest one — is an individual rather than a type, prone to spontaneous changes of mood and sometimes amusing outbursts of pettiness or ill humor.

Cinematography: 8/10 It's a bit soft-focus, but mostly OK. Has the 4:3 aspect ratio, and the image on my streaming service is smaller than most.Sound: 5/10 Actors are well-miked, but the incidental music is obnoxious.Acting: 0/10 What acting? By and large, people show up, hit their marks, read their lines. In this case, anyway, that was not enough.Screenplay: 2/10 Warlock promises to help a loser group of males at a private school. This would have been a reasonable 20 minute short, but 80 minutes? No thanks.

I put this movie into my DVD player without ever seeing the first Brotherhood or researching for this film, so I really didn't know what to expect, except that my uncle(who let me borrow it) said it was crap.It's basically about 3 outcasts who meet a a new kid at their high school named Luke who promises them whatever they want is they break the 10 Commandments and be his friends. They all agree and break 9 of the Commandments with the last one being murder.This movie is really just below average. The dialogue isn't great and it really isn't much of a horror movie as it's not scary and the horror elements don't really kick in until way after the halfway mark. If you watch this from beginning till about the halfway point, you'd think this was a coming of age teen drama with gay soft core porn.I will admit that some of the music was pretty decent, and I thought it was edited together really well. Unfortunately though, for a cult movie there is pretty much no blood, just an off screen stabbing and a sliced throat.I don't recommend this unless your a women or gay with some extra time on your hands to watch a pretty dull "horror" film.

What a complete waste of time watching this movie was, bad acting, no suspense at all, very predictable situations, not even one "magical" special effect..... and don't even let me start about the terrible make-up, everyone, man and woman, is wearing the same make-up!!

David DeCoteau has the best way of making seductive movies by pulling off before it hits the climax. The Brotherhood 2: Young Warlocks is good, but some of the characters didn't look good for the part. This movie was even cheesier then the other, but what makes this better is that their isn't as much cheesy conversations as their was in the first one. Forrest Cochran is back in this movie and was in the first Brotherhood movie and was supposed to die in the other one, but it seems he didn't and now he moves to a catholic school and seduces three guys to join his brotherhood. He then seduces a girl to get one of the guys going and start having what the group wanted. As Luc(Forrest Cochran) tells the group they most kill someone they hate to fulfill the brotherhood. One of the members of the group disapproves and finds a way to stop the madness, by quitting this little brotherhood, but isn't as easy as he thought it would be. The plot was somewhat like the first Brotherhood movie. They always seduce this girl and two guys start kissing her and all that other stuff. David DeCoteau should find a different way to make the stories longer and better and a little less sci-fi or the unreal. They are interesting though!