Just perfect...

A lot of fun.

The story, direction, characters, and writing/dialogue is akin to taking a tranquilizer shot to the neck, but everything else was so well done.

An old-fashioned movie made with new-fashioned finesse.

Curated by animators Don Hertzfeld and Mike Judge, this is a wide ranging collection of animation; computer, clay, hand-drawn, dramatic, funny, abstract, documentary. You name it. As with any collection of many shorts the quality is wide ranging too, and personal taste will play a big part in how a given person responds. But the best bits here are quite brilliant, and make this set worthwhile for fans of animation aimed at an adult audience. If Volume 2 isn't quite as filled with gems as volume 1, I was still very glad to have seen it. And given that Volume 1 and 2 currently seem to only be available as a pretty inexpensive 2-DVD box set, the total package - with a nice booklet with a biographical sketch on each of the artists represented, and a decent number of special features and extras - was an small investment I was very glad to have madeThe best of Volume 2 for my taste were: Jonathan Nix's wistful and imaginative 'Hello'. and Don Hertzfeld's wondrously funny, dark and sometimes sad "The Meaning of Life" - an oddly but potently poetic cartoon. But even the less brilliant are all interesting, with only a very few real clunkers in the bunch.Note: For me, the best of the available collections was the later Volume 3, which has a tremendously high ratio of hits to misses.

I won't review each short here separately, but in general this series is intriguing and definitely worthy a view. It starts off on the silly side with "Guard Dog", a short that, albeit a bit predictable, is still humorous and a little odd. The shorts don't really get funnier after that, but then again animation doesn't have to be funny.While I'm not too knowledgeable on the subject of why these were put together, I believe it has something to do with showcasing creative talent in animation that would otherwise pretty much go unwatched, which in my case is true being that I wouldn't have heard of any of these animators if it wasn't for Mike Judge's and Don Hertzfeldt's names put above the title. However, besides Hertzfeldt's "The Meaning of Life" (which is the weakest Hertzfeldt short to date, methinks), the real stars are the other animators.The strongest short is "Ward 13", a stop-motion animation about a patient trapped in a hellish hospital and trying to escape. It is hilarious, disturbing, and amazing all at the same time, a combination that results in the viewer staring at the screen with jaw agape once the credits start rolling at the end. It is so powerfully done with all three emotions that they tend to battle inside of you and leave you wondering what to think.If it happens to be showing somewhere around you, I'd strongly suggest going to see it. Even if you don't like the separate shorts as a whole, the feature is definitely something intriguing and creative, and it's always nice to show what can be done with a creative mind at work.--PolarisDiB

It pains me to write a mediocre review of this animation collection, but compared to the first year's collection, this batch doesn't measure up.The first Animation Show collection had a good balance between technically-interesting animation and shorts that were down-right entertaining. It was so good I saw it three times in the theater, was on the waiting list for the first round of the DVD release, and have since shown it in my home theater to friends numerous times. Naturally, I was very eager to see the 2005 collection.This year's show favored shorts that were remarkable for the technical superiority of the animation techniques, unfortunately at the expense of including many shorts with actual entertainment value. Are these shorts works of art? Undoubtedly, but I have a feeling they won't achieve anywhere near the cult-status of many of the shorts in the first collection.The only exception to my observation was Bill Plympton's "Guard Dog." Despite not being a fan of Bill Plympton, I found this short to be pretty good and worthy of a few chuckles, even if it was predictable.

Yeah, everyone knows Plympton (and "Guard Dog" was a funny short) and the stick figure guy (Hertzfeldt)'s "Meaning of Life" (which had some very funny moments), but I want to recommend seeing this collection for one of the lesser known shorts. Slight spoiler ahead: It was called "Hello" (by Jonathan Nix). It was about this character with a cassette tape player for a head, trying to work up the courage to approach a cd player head character to ask her out. He goes to his old friend the gramophone/record player head for help. Even as a generally cynical person who hates trite sentimentality I still thought the entire piece was very sweet. It was very creative, well done and the story was the right length, hit the right tones, etc. My only suggestion was to put the names of the songs in the credits.I also really liked the animation for "When the Day Breaks" (by Tilby & Forbis) - the anthromorphized animals were really well done. However the 'story' was weak. "Ward 13" (by Peter Cornwall) done in claymation was good, suspenseful and amusing.On another note, I didn't really think the computer graphic animation shorts should really have been included - or it should've been a separate section. I tend to think of that as not quite the same as non computerized animation. I look for different things and have different expectations when I watch those. However one did stick out as highly amusing, though it will only appeal to you if you have a twisted sense of humor, it's called "Fallen Art" (featuring the "Asfalt Ballet") I wont' ruin it for you by describing it but it is amusing (in a sick way) and definitely very creative.