Powerful

An Exercise In Nonsense

It's the kind of movie you'll want to see a second time with someone who hasn't seen it yet, to remember what it was like to watch it for the first time.

Like the great film, it's made with a great deal of visible affection both in front of and behind the camera.

Its World War II and those Nazi night raids are driving the British country folk balmy. When a postman is injured and rushed into surgery, he looks suspiciously at one of the doctors and one of the nurses taking on his case whom he recognizes. The next thing you know, he's gone onto that great post office in the sky and the entire staff is under suspicion for deliberately causing his death. One of the nurses (Judy Campbell) is extremely jealous of colleague Rosamund John and doctor Leo Genn (whom she discovers kissing), and at a hospital function, she denounces the postman's killer without mentioning a name, only hinting about hidden evidence that will unleash their identity. She too ends up dead, leading to a showdown with the five suspects and Inspector Cockrill (Alastair Sim), a know-it-all detective who is in for a few surprises of his own. The Inspector is the film's narrator and reveals enough clues to get the intrigue started.Tension builds at the party during a dance to "Here We Go Round the Mulberry Bush" which later becomes as dramatic a theme music as Alfred Hitchcock used with "The Merry Widow Waltz" in "Shadow of a Doubt" and "The Strawberry Blonde" in "Strangers on a Train". The film can be rather slow in spots, but as the surprises explode, the film just gets more and more amusing. It is astonishing to note that the film seems technically advanced beyond its release year as some British films tended to seem compared to the studio controlled product in Hollywood. Director Sidney Gilliat doesn't give us a slower paced narrative for no reason; Every detail is explored. The film's photography is outstanding. Other than Trevor Howard, Alastair Sim and Leo Genn, the cast may not be familiar to a lot of American viewers, but everybody is fine and each of them have great moments to shine. Stick with the film and you'll be greatly amused by the twists and turns in the plot that you don't see coming. Sim, best known to American audiences for perhaps the most popular version of "A Christmas Carol", plays a role I thought might be a continuing character in other films, but I was mistaken. He seemed very comfortable in the part for this to have been a regular role for him. He has a great final surprise and his response to it is ingenious.

Thoroughly entertaining, this whodunit is set amid the bombing raids in London in 1944, but the plot only tangentially touches on the War. Most scenes take place in or near a hospital. And all of the suspects are hospital staff, identified early and efficiently. As the camera slowly pans an operating room, the story narrator identifies six main characters, doctors and nurses, all dressed in surgical gowns, masks, and caps. "Two of these people (will) be dead, and one of them a murderer".Into this setting comes Inspector Cockrill (Alastair Sim), quick-on-the-uptake, self-assured, and humorously pompous. He learns the details of the crime, interviews the suspects, and then, at the end, recreates the operating room setting wherein the first person was murdered, hoping to trap the killer.The film abounds with subtle clues and red herrings. That's what makes the film enjoyable. Yet, in reviewing the film, I can see that one of the most important clues is really too subtle. And that's my main criticism. Nevertheless, viewers can find all the clues they need to solve the mystery, in the first 20 to 25 minutes of the film, if they really pay attention.B&W cinematography is effective in creating a suspenseful, taut, noir atmosphere, particularly in the operating room scenes. The cinematography is less effective outdoors. But outdoor scenes were actually filmed inside a studio.Good acting amplifies the high quality production. Leo Genn, Judy Campbell, and Megs Jenkins are all quite effective. And, of course, Alastair Sim is terrific."Green For Danger" presents viewers with a murder mystery attended to by a humorously eccentric inspector. It also conveys a realistic look at civilians trying to cope amid the stress and uncertainty of wartime, and thus has thematic value beyond the whodunit element.

The quintessential 40s British whodunit, Green for Danger satisfies even as it leaves a trail of plot holes that even Alistair Sims' rather self-satisfied Inspector Cockrill would have spotted. Perhaps it satisfies despite its flaws because it embodies all the good things about British films back then. The writers assume a level of intelligence on the part of their viewers and possession of an attention span that would seem unattainable to many of today's MTV generation. Time is taken to develop characters and establish relationships instead of telling the audience everything about a character that is necessary only for the purpose of driving the plot along.Alistair Sim, sporting a typically smug grin when he's not ducking airplanes, plays Inspector Cockrill, who is called upon to investigate the murder of a postman on the operating table at a quaint hospital full of wooden beams and flagstone floors. He doesn't appear until midway through the film – although his voice can be heard on the narration from the outset – and his dry wit peps things up immeasurably. We are presented with the usual group of suspects: Leo Genn as a vaguely slimy Lothario who wastes no time in pursuing the lovely nurse Fredericka (Sally Gray) the moment she breaks off her engagement to a young Trevor Howard; buxom Megs Jenkins, a matronly figure even then although she was still in her twenties, and a nurse who borders on the edge of hysteria nearly all the time. They were all present at an operation in which poor old Moore Marriott was pumped full of Co2, and are all, therefore, suspected of his murder.The film keeps you guessing throughout – knowing very little about the film before I watched it, I couldn't even figure out who the second victim was going to be for a while: the plot seemed to be setting up one character for the fall before turning the spotlight on someone else entirely. A couple of red herrings throw you off the trail quite nicely, and Inspector Cockrill's confidence proves to be monumentally misplaced. The twist at the end is truly sublime, and the look on Alistair Sim's face when all becomes clear is one of those cinematic moments that live long in the memory. It's all very quaint and old-fashioned now, but it still provides some solid entertainment.

A superb, morbidly funny WWII-era murder mystery set in the makeshift hospital of a small English village.A postman injured during a bombing dies inexplicably while being prepped for surgery, even though his condition was not life threatening. Enter a cocky and irascible private detective (Alastair Sim), who believes one of the five medical personnel who had a hand in the surgery is a murderer.Forget trying to figure this one out ahead of time. In classic murder mystery fashion, the motive for the murder comes out of left field at the very end. No, the fun here is in the journey, and in Sim's scene-stealing performance as a detective in love with his own abilities. The movie has a delicious twist at the end that has to do more with Sim's detective (and said abilities) than with the murder suspect.A wonderful, overlooked film. Thanks to Criterion for releasing it and bringing it to people's attention.Grade: A