Beautiful, moving film.

A Masterpiece!

It's funny, it's tense, it features two great performances from two actors and the director expertly creates a web of odd tension where you actually don't know what is happening for the majority of the run time.

Close shines in drama with strong language, adult themes.

This is actually a pretty enjoyable movie, for kids and older viewers. It's very creative, some odd but funny aspects, and quirky with the filming style and the mixed-up way of story telling. Like I said, it's not for everyone, but if you're okay with not everything making 100% sense, it's pretty fun.In, sort of a Pulp Fiction style, it tells the story in mixed around shorts, it's really easy to connect them and figure out what order they go in, and it's pretty obvious it's a gimmick ​or gimmick's ​​sake, but it's still fun, and I don't give it any hate for that.For ages 5-10, I'd give it a 9For ages 11-14, I'd give it a 7 or 8For ages 15-20, I'd give it a 6 or 7For ages 21+, I'd give it a 4 or 5But I, 16, found it very enjoyable, and give it a 6.5

Told in a very disjointed style, Shorts tells the tale of a group of children and adults living in the secluded Black Falls community where the popular Black Box all-in-one gadget is created. A rainbow coloured "wishing rock" falls from the sky during a rain storm, and bizarrely imaginative wishes are granted one-by-one for everyone that gets their hands on it. But not all wishes are as good as others.Robert Rodriguez, an all-in-one filmmaker unlike any other, has created another imaginative family film I imagine he is proud of because he can sit and watch it with his children. While the man made his bones on bullet strewn bloody epics like Desperado and Frank Miller's Sin City, he has never been one to shy away from the family genre. But with every entry, the work just continues to become sloppier. Inspired by his children or not, Rodriguez must have known Shorts was a bad idea from the start. But this clearly mattered very little.I am clearly in the wrong demographic to even begin deciphering what works and what does not in Shorts, but the film is a mess from start to finish. Employing a bit of the style of his buddy Quentin Tarantino, Rodriguez fashions the movie to work as smaller, unorganized stories within a grander framework (thus explaining the title of this opus). It is never confusing, but it becomes really annoying listening to the narrator, main character Toby "Toe" Thompson (Jimmy Bennett) tell us he does not remember the way the story goes every time the story jumps back or forward. Even worse is the addition of rewind, fast forward, and pause buttons that keep appearing during the film. Sure it is quirky and amusing the first time it shows up, but it just becomes bothersome and irritating as the film goes on. It really makes no sense why it is not told in any chronological order and just seems like Rodriguez mixed it up just to make the film a bit more interesting than it actually is.The film's storyline, as simplistic as it is, really offers nothing new to the family genre. Inherent issues about crumbling family units, making friends, and just genuinely finding your place in the world have all been done to death, as have stories about people wishing for things. And while some of the issues do succeed in being imaginative and unique, the stereotypical family film issues are anything but. Rodriguez throws them all into the film (and even a minor subplot about small green aliens) with a no-holds barred attitude dictated by a man who could care less what people think. And when the film reaches its credits, it really feels like all he did was throw ideas at the wall and went with the ones that stuck.As said, the imaginative wishes provided throughout the film by every character are what make the film. A booger monster, walking crocodiles and a baby who can speak to other through her mind are just the start of what you can expect to see during Shorts. And as the film goes on, the ideas just become sillier and more creative as they go along. But sadly, they do not appear all appear to be coming from the mind of Rodriguez. And that is where the film hits another bad turn: the special effects that create these wishes leaves a lot to be desired. Almost every single one looks freakishly amateur and unpolished. I know Rodriguez does a lot of the work himself, but after watching something as digital and special effects friendly as Frank Miller's Sin City, and how realistic that looks, it is a bit sad to look at this mess of a film as being from the same film-making group. It just feels all too disappointing, and like it was just pumped out too quickly before it was really perfected.The acting, much like the rest of the film, is not all that great. Bennett is amusing in the lead role, giving everything he can as a child actor. Yet it does not seem like he was provided much to do outside of what the script asks for. He has a much stronger presence as a supporting character in Orphan, and was better even in his minuscule role as Young Kirk in the recent Star Trek reimagining. I was much more impressed with newcomer Jolie Vanier as the villainess Helvetica. She appears to have really dug into her bad girl role, and is given ample opportunity to make something of the role. And in a movie like this, that is never really all too hard. Adult actors like Kat Dennings, William H. Macy, Jon Cryer, Leslie Mann and James Spader are all given a fair amount to do, but never really seem to give it their all. They just seem to be going through the motions, acting as ridiculous and goofy as they need to, and not doing much else.I started writing this review a few weeks ago after seeing the film, but forgot about finishing it. After watching the movie, it feels like Rodriguez acted the same way when he was writing and putting the film together. There are a few shells of interesting ideas that are on display at various points throughout the film, but they are never fully realized. I can really appreciate the family aspect of the production, and how much of a one-man team Rodriguez is. But this is just not a great film. It has imagination, but it lacks the ability to really stretch and mold it into something worthwhile. It easily could have been made into a stronger film if anyone on the team really put some effort into it. As it is, the newcomer Vanier is the only real reason to even attempt to sit through it.3/10.(Portions of this review originally appeared on http://www.dvdfanatic.com).

This is a cute movie at times, but apparently aimed at the very young because it is mostly silliness all the way through. I tried to watch it in its entirety, but after a half-hour began viewing about 30 seconds of a chapter then advancing to the next chapter on the DVD.I also suspect that while Rodriguez is very good at directing and producing a movie, he isn't as accomplished as a writer. Recall his first genuine effort, El Mariachi, has very little dialog in it. Sin City, which is very good, was written by someone else. It reminds me of that other young auteur, Night Shamalayan, who also is a good director but, from my point of view, a lousy writer.This movie, "Shorts", gets it name from the narration by the boy who tells us, the audience, in a series of short films. It begins with showing us the usual cliché school kids and bullies, but all that is to set us up for the discovery of the rainbow-colored rock which has the power to grant wishes.The adult story has James Spader as Mr Carbon Black who heads Black Box Industries and is trying to perfect a black box type of gadget that can do just about everything. As he says, it would be easier to name the things it cannot do.In the end there is a moral, if you wish for things make sure they are good things. But overall not a very good movie, but maybe entertaining for the very young. "I wish I could watch it again when I am 7 years old."

Robert Rodriguez's wild children's film proves once again that he is one of the most imaginative minds working in films today. Say what you will about his speed and economy of filming (his kids films often look a bit cheap) he manages to fill the void with more craziness than almost any three other films aimed at kids. Rodriguez seems to think like a kid and can translate it to the big screen.Here he's come up with the tale of what happens when a rainbow colored wishing rock falls to earth. Found by kids they set about making their dreams come true. The problem really come to the fore when the adults get their hands on the magic of the rock.Rodriguez has fashioned a fantastical story about what getting our dreams really means (told in a series of shorts of the title) but also a morality tale about dreams and business. Its a fun little movie thats also good for you. For the most part I think he manages to hit the target with some laughs and some out loud mumbled "oh cools". The cast, which includes John Cryer, William H Macy and James Spader, is on point and really sells the craziness. The effects are quite good and manage to tread the fine line between serious and silly.If the film falls down anywhere its perhaps that things are a bit too much at times (too many characters, too much motion). Because this is a short film, its under 90 minutes, Rodriguez also relies a bit too much on cliché short hand with a hero who thinks he has no friends when he does, and bad guys who really aren't. While I like the characters I wish they had been a bit less stock.Over all though I liked this film. I don't think its quite worth paying full movie theater prices for it, but on cable or DVD (which is probably best because you can back up the movie) I think this is worth a shot.