Luke spoils Madelein with a luxurious life in Colombia, and worries she'll leave him if it all falls apart. Ani hopes Kyle will trade his sperm donation hobby for a traditional life with her. Shawn fell in love with Douglas, but three years later, his boyfriend is living as a woman.

Shawn sees Alliya for the first time since she began living as a woman. Alex doesn't want her boyfriend Adriano to pressure her into threesomes. Kyle's odd behaviors make Ani wonder if she's making the right decision. Luke and Madelein reunite in Colombia, but he dreads revealing the truth about his finances.

Ani confronts Kyle and asks if he has donated sperm through sex while dating her. Shawn is unsure if he can reconcile who Alliya is now with the person he fell in love with. Luke confesses to Madelein that he lost his job. Alex arrives in Italy and tells Adriano it's her or threesomes.

Luke reveals to Madelein that he's not moving to Colombia.

Tensions flare between Luke and Madelein when he brings up a prenup. Alex is concerned she may be forcing her relationship with Adriano because she feels behind in life. Shawn worries about their future as Alliya says goodbye to Douglas. Kyle and Ani get emotional and decide someone needs to compromise.

Alex meets Adriano's mother and makes a plea for her religion. Madelein breaks down when Luke hesitates while visiting a wedding venue. Kyle gets an STD test as Ani looks to a friend for advice. Shawn plans a big surprise for Alliya.

Alliya expresses concerns about Shawn having all the control in their relationship. Ani says Kyle has never been in love before, and she sees his messy apartment. While on a romantic getaway, Luke can't stop thinking about a rumor he heard about Madelein.