Expected more

Don't listen to the Hype. It's awful

Through painfully honest and emotional moments, the movie becomes irresistibly relatable

It is an exhilarating, distressing, funny and profound film, with one of the more memorable film scores in years,

An overseas commentator once said he would rather sit through a Lars Von Trier festival than watch an Australian comedy. Up until the recent "Any Questions for Ben?", and with the exception of "The Castle" and "Babe", I'd say he had a point. In fact, "Strange Planet" could be that Australian comedy he was talking about.Sadly, "Australian comedy" has been problematic (i.e. not funny) for decades. Although "Strange Planet" has pretensions to be a comment on the social mores of young, upper middle class Australians as opposed to a straight-out comedy, the filmmakers surely must have intended it to be funnier than it is.Set in Sydney, the movie is about three women who have been friends at university – Judy, Alice and Sally played by Claudia Karvin, Naomi Watts and Alice Garner – and three men who are starting their careers in the legal profession, Ewan, Joel and Neil played by Tom Long, Aaron Jeffery and Felix Williamson. The two groups do not know each other at the beginning of the film but their lives become enmeshed as the story unfolds. The story takes place over one year. So much is packed into this film that it is surprising that it seems to drag so much. Alarm bells sound early. As Judy and her friends leave a supermarket, Judy's boss, who is obsessed with her, asks her to marry him – on his knees no less. The scene is overplayed for comic potential but none is forthcoming; the whole sequence is contrived and miss-timed."Strange Planet" like many Australian films, comedies or otherwise, is too talky. When the script runs out of things for the characters to say, they read from magazines, books and astrology guides – anything to keep up the flow of verbiage. Much of the character motivation is revealed in sessions with psychoanalysts. Both Neil and Alice are seeing therapists – yet another way to keep the cast talking.The characters, men and women alike, constantly give each other advice. The script is full of pet theories espoused by one or other of the principals. Neil's character in particular has many theories, mostly about women. One of his theories is that one can tell what a woman is like from her handbag – this pertains somewhat to physical attributes and gives an idea of the level of wit in the movie.Everything is so superficial in this film that broken relationships, date rape, suicide attempts, sex scenes and self-discovery, all run together without generating much emotion. Although the underlying problem with "Strange Planet" is that it is a collection of poorly conceived sequences that don't hang together, it is the overall sense of self satisfaction that finally sinks the film for me. "Strange Planet", strange movie.

In Australia, New Year finds two different groups of friends, 3 men and 3 women, begin their years in a variety of different ways, however each has ambitions and resolutions relating to their love lives. However, during the course of the following year things don't go quite as they would have foreseen or hoped in most cases.This film relates to the topic that is hardly new ground - that of love and relationships in our modern age. In the same way, the manner in which the film tells it's story will also seem like it's not doing anything new in a new way, for it isn't. The film homage's (or rips off) several recent (at the time) films such as Shallow Grave and Trainspotting for it's visual style as well as other `youf' romantic comedies for it's content (as well as a seemingly pointless venture off into Taxi Driver territory that does nothing but prove the writers once watched Taxi Driver!).However, having said that, it still does manage to be quite entertaining and have it's own rough bit of charm to it. It isn't really very funny at any point but it does manage to be quite realistically downbeat without being totally depressing. If anything this rather bleak view of relationships is quite realistic and refreshingly honest - a shame then that it goes and plumps for a happy ending of sorts which relies on coincidence and the usual unlikely devices of romantic comedies. The characters are not that well drawn but they have enough realism to them to make them recognisable and their problems and experiences also relatable. Having 2 groups of 3 character does overstretch the film somewhat though, and some issues are not really dealt with in any meaningful way (an attempted rape just seems to happen without any follow up for instance), but on the whole it works reasonably well.I'm not sure if the cast are well known in Australia, but I had never seen any of them before (with the exception of Watts and Weaving of course). This helped the characters a bit, as I only knew them as who they were playing. Some of the male actors struggled a bit and it is the three female leads that have the best parts - Watts and Karvan having the meatier characters but Garner being cute, sexy and fun!Overall this film is not original or different from many other films you could see, but it's bleak view of modern relationships is interesting and involving (until it blows it) and the characters were recognisable enough to involve me in the film for the duration.

If, like me, you liked _Love and other catatastrophes_, then you'll probably like this too. It's not quite a sequel, but it does follow young Aussies thru the period just after college. It concerns three fairly likeable guys and three not-unattractive girls in this in the awkward but enjoyable phase of life, and views their often quirky attitudes to relationships with a non-judgemental eye. It's full of humour, and it's only major faults are that some of the characters and plotlines are a bit cliched and you can see the ending coming from a long way back.

Rating - 4 stars (out of 5)Too many reviewers have tried to compare Emma-Kate Croghan's second feature with her first, Love and Other Catastrophes. Well you'd expect that, since they are relatively the same subject matter. I'm not though, because I have not seen it. But I will most definitely see it soon, because I was very impressed with "Strange Planet".It's not often that directors play it straight off the bat. Most try to pull off something amazing and fail miserably, others go for the 'play it dumb' method to make it accessible for everyone, as Steven (Hugo Weaving) so rightly puts it in the film. Croghan as a director oozes class; she knows what she is doing. In other hands it could have been very messy.The tagline is perhaps the best summary of the film one could put it. Three girls, three guys, 365 days to get it together. We follow the trials and tribulations of the two separate groups, who encounter the usual mid-twenties "What am I going to do with life?" crisis, fall in and out of love, rave parties etc etc. All told with amusing results. Though the material is far from original, I never felt as if I needed to scream out "I've seen it ALL before!!!". Croghan adds in her own dose of tricks along the way to make sure it definitely sets it apart from other films, for example watch out for the ongoing discussion of a lady's handbag!Claudia Karvan wonderfully plays Judy who begins the film with so much assurance but begins to lose herself as her world starts falling apart. Naomi Watts (Alice) is great too and easy to watch. In fact all the actors gave first class performances. There is so much to like about the film, that the ending comes as a bit of a let down. It's the ending you want for the characters, but not exactly the right ending for you. A little too sentimental and over-done and way too predictable.Australian films have come a long way since Gallipoli, Strictly Ballroom and even the recent Shine. No longer are we compelled to just one or two great films a year. We are producing them like never before. Strange Planet sits with the best of them this year - Two Hands and Siam Sunset. With Croghan, Karvan and Watts we have many good things to look forward to.