Memorable, crazy movie

Excellent, Without a doubt!!

It's entirely possible that sending the audience out feeling lousy was intentional

The film's masterful storytelling did its job. The message was clear. No need to overdo.

Forget Wolverine and Van Helsing when you go into the magical world of Hugh Jackman's participation in musical theater. He rocked Broadway as Peter Allen (Liza Minnelli's first gay husband) in "The Boy From Oz" and was standing room only in a musical revue. Nobody could replace him as Peter Allen, so the show only ran a year to sold out crowds (and he never missed a performance!) and got him a well deserved Tony Award. For those who missed that show that never made it onto the small screens or made into a movie, there's the PBS version of "Oklahoma!" which he did in London prior to taking on his more iconic roles. While Patrick Wilson would take over the role in the Broadway transfer, much of that cast who was on stage at the Gershwin Theater in 2002 is here, a nice visit to a show I had the privilege of seeing and got to re-visit thanks to the availability of this version.Certainly, it's going to be a bit jarring to hear the Australian born Jackman singing as American cowboy Curly, but he makes it work simply on his charm and his ability to sing and dance as gracefully as Astaire and Kelly, be funny, yet never make you doubt that he's as masculine (not macho) as they come. His confidence as a performer is unmatchable, although I didn't feel his chemistry with Josefina Gabrielle (Laurey) was as strong as it could have been. She's a great singer, and certainly pretty, but I think is the one weak link in an otherwise strong production. Maureen Lipman's Aunt Eller is strong, funny, loving, commanding and everybody's first stop when they need advice. While I saw Andrea Martin take on this role (and absolute perfection), it's Lipman's who will remain in viewer's minds because of her presence on the video and in TV productions.A Tony Award went to Shuler Hensley in the usually thankless role of the "villain" Jud Fry who gets to show more dimensions than usual in this production. He's only a villain really at the end, mostly a misunderstood loner who doesn't have social graces and is perhaps too shy to deal with women in a gentle manner. He also knows that he's ugly and unlovable, and that adds a sense of heartbreak into his character, making you think about your own feelings towards people in life who don't fill the mold of what a desirable man or woman should be. Vicki Simon is perfectly fine as Ado Annie, the "girl who cain't say no", with Jimmy Johnston just as memorable as her long suffering fiancée Will, determined to raise the money he needs to give Ado Annie's father in order to get his permission to marry her.The set is perfect, with the corn really as high as an elephant's eye, and cute model trains representing the visits to Kansas City and back. The choreography is outstanding, the orchestrations truly beautiful, and the ensemble filled with really talented, attractive dancers who do a great justice to Rodgers and Hammerstein's fabulous score. Fortunately, the success of this show got PBS to air the Lincoln Center production of "South Pacific" and a concert version of "Carousel" (my own favorite Rodgers and Hammerstein show), but this being the first Rodgers and Hammerstein show to which I knew the entire score (through an early viewing of this when I was just a kid), "Oklahoma!" holds a special place in my heart: for the movie, for the 2002 Broadway revival, and for the TV Broadcast of this production which shows that this has stood the test of time and has everything great that represents the best of what America is all about.

OKLAHOMA! opened on Broadway in 1943 and became a classic - not only because the Rodgers and Hammerstein score was so strong, but also because Agnes De Mille was brought in to introduce serious choreography to the Broadway stage. For the past 64 years this musical comedy/drama has been on the boards both professionally and in high schools, colleges and community theaters and always meets with audience acclaim. In 1999 Trevor Nunn reshaped the work, added choreography by Susan Stroman, beefed up the orchestrations, and re-staged the old warhorse in London and the result is an entirely fresh look and appreciation for an 'American classic'.Nunn opens the inner conflicts of the story and emphasizes some of the more minor characters, a move that adds to the dramatic flow of the work. Yet his biggest asset is the presence of Hugh Jackman as Curly, a handsome stage presence who also happens to possess a strong baritone singing voice and is an agile dancer. From the opening bars of 'Oh, what a beautiful morning' he has us in his back pocket. The remainder of the cast is strong, with special kudos to Maureen Lipman as Aunt Eller, a woman of such plainsman power that she holds the story together with ease. Josefina Gabrielle as Laurey is a fine dancer and has a supple if monochromatic voice and brings a different kind of life to her role. And for once the sinister Jud Fry becomes an understandable villain in the fine work by Shuler Hensley.For those who don't like audible applause from an audience during a show the technique of making the film appear like a live production will disturb. For this viewer seeing the British audience become involved in the response of this musical made it that much more fun. This is a very fine performance and film of an old American treasure. Grady Harp

I really enjoyed this movie,in fact I loved it. At first I wasn't to sure I would like this movie because I hadn't known it was a musical when I had pick it out. If I had to con-pair to a movie which of course would have to be another music movie. I would say it's pretty daron good compared to Sing In The Rain and with Gene Kelly. Wow.....Hugh Jackman can really sing and act....and all that. The story keep me interested and I want to see more and what was going to happen next....and if it would have a happy ending. I like movies with a happy endings. It did have a happy ending and it also had drama a romance which are both good for me in a movie. I would watch over and over again.

I originally tuned into PBS' broadcast because I was curious about Hugh Jackman's singing. - He was absolutely charismatic. It was too bad that Curly didn't have more stage time! I hope I can see him live in a musical or in a play sometime soon. Film work just does not do justice to his talents.While I tuned in out of curiosity, the updated production, exuberant musical numbers, staging, and dancing kept my attention. This production of "Oklahoma!" re-affirms my love of live theatre.