Simply Perfect

People are voting emotionally.

Entertaining from beginning to end, it maintains the spirit of the franchise while establishing it's own seal with a fun cast

Good films always raise compelling questions, whether the format is fiction or documentary fact.

I have enjoyed this film for many years. Casting a film is an art in itself. And this film is a classic of casting. The Oscar-winning actor Jack Lemmon, is a perfect foil for the fussy Ernie Kovacs. Young James Darren, and Dick York, and the inimitable Mickey Rooney, all make a fine ensemble. Veteran Arthur O'Connell, and all of the rest serve up a delicious film.This is one of the biggest sleepers of all time, and really never got the recognition that it deserved. I like to think of it as a "Proto-M*A*S*H", as it clearly presents a lunacy of a military hospital, and the goofy characters.A precious "gem" of a film.

Remember MASH (1970)? Well. This movie predates it, and in this one the medical corps also throws plenty of spanners that inevitably gum up the way of the army. Of course, this earlier movie doesn't have the total irreverence of Mash, but there is the same abuse and misuse of army regulations, which inevitably leads to the double takes of the usual, flabbergasted and endlessly (and always uselessly) flabbergasted officers. Unfortunately, this movie does not come across with anything like the same success, thanks to surprisingly heavy-handed direction by Richard Quine (a genial man, noted for his friendly approach and light touch), plus the script's over-reliance on dialogue that is both over- repetitive and tiresomely prone to milk the very last grains of humor from situations that were not really all that funny to begin with.

It's post World War II France, and sergeant Hogan (Jack Lemmon) is threatened with court martial by Captain Ernie Kovacs with every antic even though the commanding colonel (Arthur O'Connell) stands up for him. Who's running the hospital here, anyway? There's lots of silly pranks and antics in Lemmon's effort to throw the maddest military ball to end all military balls, all the while complaining of an ulcer he gets assistance from pretty nurse Kathryn Crosby for.Only moderately amusing, this has a good cast and the benefit of future comedy legend Blake Edwards as one of its four writers. But if it looked funny on paper, something has been left off the screen, perhaps thanks to director Richard Quine who directed a few military comedies (a few with songs starring Mickey Rooney), all pretty forgettable. Rooney appears here too, but his participation seemingly something of an afterthought and no real addition to the script. "Bewitched" fans will appreciate Dick York in a major supporting role. This just ends up being nothing but another one of many anti-military comedy where they are made to seem like buffoons.

An easy-going bumbling Colonel commands a military hospital, the 1066th. A self-serving martinet second-in-command tries to use military regulations to tyrannize over the hospital staff. A fun-loving conniver wants to give the hospital staffers a chance to enjoy the company of the hospital's nurses while the second-in-command tries to thwart him. If Jack Lemmon and his friends had been doctors and officers, instead of enlisted personnel, the general resemblance to MASH would have been complete. When Richard Hooker's novel MASH was turned into a TV series (after passing through the movies), the writers must have been familiar with this movie. Curiouser and curiouser.